Cookout Secret Menu – Hidden Items You Need to Try

Have you ever wondered if the restaurant you visit has a secret side? Just because you don’t see it doesn’t mean you don’t smell it or taste it at Cookout, the home of bold southern flavors. The Cookout’s secret menu offers a hidden collection of dishes behind the scenes, and if you are brave enough to ask, you would find.

Below are 19 secret menu items to help you unlock the mystery in 2025!

What’s Hidden on the Cookout Secret Menu?

Hi, all flavor seekers and Cookout fans! Cookout has a secret menu full of delicious dishes, sides, shakes, and drinks that you’ll not find on the regular menu. The secret to southern-style BBQ lies with those loyal customers who know what real southern-style BBQ tastes like.

So being a food lover and adventurous, are you ready to explore the secret treasures of your own city, that spot just a little further away from your everyday life? Here’s where I want you to let the delicious surprises await you!

Must-Try Secret Items on the Cookout Menu

Just imagine the hidden gems of Cookout’s secret menu as a treasure map divided into five excellent sections. Wow! It means you can always enjoy something for your craving: unique main dishes, secretive sides, exclusive sauces and creamy, nontraditional shakes. So let’s uncover what’s on the secret menu.

Note:  it’s important to note that secret menu items are not officially recognized in all Cook Out locations or availability may change. However, you should first verify with your Cook Out to find out if it could be customized.

Secret Main Dishes at Cookout

Here, I am sharing the long list of hidden main dishes that are available at Cookout, including those unseen on the regular menu. If you want to enhance your dining experience, you must try these secret entrées!

Everything Burger

A double cheeseburger that has many toppings. The good thing is that you can customize it and add chili, onion rings, lettuce, tomato, and pickles, among many other options to make your meal more flavorful.

Firecracker Hot Dog

If you are a spice lover, then you must know that the secret menu Cookout has created the “Firecracker Hot Dog”  for you!  If you want this, you’ll get chopped onions, chili, mustard, and ketchup. You can also add a lot of Cajun seasoning to make your meal fiery.

Peanut Butter Paradise Burger

The coolest thing about Cookout’s secret menu is the “Peanut Butter Paradise Burger” which brings savory and sweet taste together. If you want to order this burger, then you just need to ask for a regular hamburger with the beef patty, and then ask to be specifically given the peanut butter spread on it when you order.

BBQ Tray with Sandwich Slaw

One of my favorites at Cook Out (which mirrors their BBQ Plate) is to add the “BBQ Tray with Sandwich Slaw” as a customization. If you need this order, then you can just request a BBQ Tray and chow down on coleslaw, hushpuppies, and fries.

Texas Pete with Chicken Quesadilla

Texas Pete Chicken Quesadilla is a cookout’s secret menu item that is filled with grilled chicken, melted cheese, and Texas Pete hot sauce. In combination, however, these give an extra fiery streak to the regular quesadilla.

Tacos

If you are tired of traditional wrapping, be happy now as Cookout’s secret menu has added a “Tacos” item just for you! If you want to order this, you would request a taco and tell them what you want inside, seasoned beef, grilled chicken, lettuce, tomato, cheese, and sauces.

Mexi Dog

Cook Out’s ‘Mexi Dog’ is a spicy secret menu item, a hot dog with the topping of cheddar cheese, chili, and a drizzle of Texas Pete hot sauce, diced onions. But even many Cookout locations will be able to make it upon request.

Cookout’s Secret Side Options

The secret side items are those which you won’t see on the regular sides menu. I have listed some of their items you must try to experience the unique flavors you never even thought of!

Grilled Cheese

It’s a simple, but tasty, secret menu item. It’s a hit of melted cheese between toast. You also have a chance to customize it by putting in some tomatoes or bacon inside it.

Fried Okra

It has another secret menu item, that’s not on their menu, but you can ask for it anyway. It’s golden, crispy, seasoned, and a Southern snack that can be enjoyed with other dishes. All you’ve got to do is ask for it when ordering!

Hushpuppies

Hushpuppies are crispy golden fried cornbread balls with a soft middle that would make a great side to whatever you are eating. If you order them, just ask for them. It’s a Southern favorite!

Bacon and Grilled Onion Fries

These are a version of their famous fries served on the secret menu. These are literally topped with crispy bacon, and smoky grilled onions, combined with fries to give a savory, smoky flavor. You just ask for this combination whenever you want to order.

Cookout Secret Milkshakes

Find out the secret milkshakes you didn’t know about at Cookout that have delicious unexpected flavors. Just trust me, these hidden treats make your dessert experience that much better!

Cookies and Cream Freakshake

It’s a thick milkshake with a topping of crushed cookies and cream. It’s topped with whipped cream, more cookies, and sometimes even a touch of chocolate or fudge that makes it a perfect treat for those who love the dessert. Just ask for it by name!

Nilla Wafers in Shakes

Now you can add crushed Nilla Wafers to any Cookout milkshake for some extra flavor and texture. This creamy shake, when combined with the soft, sweet cookies, makes something uniquely delicious. Just ask the staff to add them!

Pumpkin Pie Shake

It’s a Cookout’s seasonal secret menu item, a creamy pumpkin pie spice shake. This is the perfect fall treat, a thick refreshing shake with cinnamon, nutmeg, and pumpkin flavors all combined. All you have to do is ask for it when it’s available.

Peanut Butter & M&M Shake

This secret menu item is a creamy peanut butter and crunchy M&M’s in a milkshake. It’s a great combination of sweet to salty, and it’s a treat, at the same time! So when you order, just ask for it!

Chocolate Banana Pudding Shake

This secret menu item is made with the decadent tastes of chocolate and banana pudding in a milkshake that’s too creamy. It is a special combo of sweets, a creamy and fruity treat for sweet lovers. Just order and ask for it when you want to order!

Secret Desserts at Cookout

Find out which one of Cookout’s secret desserts is going to satisfy your sweet tooth. These hidden treats add an extra dose of indulgence to your meal, and you won’t find these flavors anywhere else!

Walnut Brownie

It is a rich, fudgy brownie that is served with crunchy walnuts. If you are the type of person who loves chocolate and nuts combined, then this is the perfect dessert for you! When you order, just ask for it by name!

Cheesecake Extravaganza

This secret menu is a delicious creamy cheesecake enriched with all sorts of flavorful additions. It might contain strawberries, whipped cream, or some melted chocolate for all those fancy cheese feeling that serves the purpose of a dessert.

Create Your Unique Secret Menu Combination at Cookout

The first key to unlocking the secret menu of Cookout is to learn how to take their existing items and modify them to allow you to create something interesting and new. Choose the dishes, sides, and shakes that best suit you and blend them to create the custom-made meal you want.

Here’s how you can better customize and maximize your Cookout experience!

Get Creative with Your Toppings

Trust me, you won’t be afraid to get creative with your hot dogs and burgers. Try some BBQ sauce on an onion ring on a cheeseburger. Go ahead! Or If you want to try something different, get yourself a hot dog with chili, and a salad on the side.

Mix and Match Your Milkshakes

In fact, at Cookout, you can really make your dream milkshake; blend your favorite flavors to create the one you want. What about cherry and chocolate, or bananas and peanut butter? There are a lot of combinations to explore!

Think Outside the Box

Why settle with a typical BBQ tray? If you don’t get hushpuppies or fried okra, request that they bring you another dish on the side for extra excitation and flavor. Choose according to your taste!

Hidden Side Combinations at Cookout

The side combos found on the Cookout secret menu include grilled cheese, fried okra, and bacon fries. On top of that, your BBQ tray has room to add extra slaw, fries, and hushpuppies. And this combination only gets better with a bite of the Cookout Chicken Wrap in each mouthful.

Secret Seasonal Offerings at Cookout

Secret seasonal specials at Cookout make fans go wild, with unique flavors that come with each season. Though it’s for Halloween, try the Pumpkin Spice Shake as this combines pumpkin pie, nutmeg, and cinnamon. During fall, enjoy the Apple Pie Shake, made with apple pie, butter, and cinnamon at the perfect time.

Thirdly, when it is spring, get the Strawberry Shortcake Shake which contains real strawberry shortcake added to a creamy vanilla shake.

Tips to Order The Cookout Secret Menu

Be polite and patient: You may need a little longer to change your order. Be nice to the staff and let them do your work.

Stay Within Limits: You can customize your order anytime you want, but make it sensible. Don’t burden the staff into making too many changes at one time.

Be Bold with Your Choices: Don’t be afraid to try! Try new flavor combinations at the Cookout secret menu until you find the flavor combinations that you simply must have together.

Frequently Asked Questions

Conclusion

Many people don’t know about the hidden secrets in the Cookout secret menu. You can always choose custom shakes or different side options, or you may even find seasonal items. No matter if you’ve been a regular customer of Cookout for years, or this is your first time, you should always try and request the secret menu to make your trip even more fun! Or you can order your secret menu favorites from the comfort of your home.